The Hottest Models who Turned into WWE Divas

3. Michelle McCool

She’s probably one of the best Diva Search success stories in the WWE. Fun fact, she started out as a middle school teacher. The longtime wrestling fan entered the 2004 contest, and spent a better part of 8 years as a cornerstone in the Women’s division.

Since she was naturally athletic, she took on wrestling with a lot of ease compared to other Diva search entrants. She clearly knew what she was doing in the ring. Her first run as a blonde with an annoying babyface was a complete flop, but after teaming up with Layla El, there was no stopping her.